Alors que le jeu Brothers In Arms n'est sorti que depuis quelques jours, les reviews pleuvent comme des petits pains. Cette fois, c'est au tour de PC Gameworld de tester la bête et de lui trouver plus de qualités que de défauts, même si le journaliste termine son article sur une conclusion mi figue mi raisin :

« Overall, I would say that BIA is an average World War II shooter, with elements of strategy implemented somewhat successfully. However, the game is also available on consoles, and I can't help but think the game would have been so much better had it been developed solely for PC. As a PC shooter, I would only really recommend it if you can find it significantly cheaper than full price. Despite all that it does right, there are still many aspects of the game left wanting. »